Follow

Why did I venture into the comments section on a post about Jodie Whittaker's outfit from the new Doctor Who teaser? I was perfectly content not knowing how many people apparently violently dislike the last season. My bad for thinking The Mary Sue readers were different, I guess...
(For the record, I enjoyed it for the most part, and I love the 13th Doctor and her gaggle of companions.)

@shirasade I thought it was perfectly good Doctor Who. I'm not sure I really engage with it the way I did at the time for the rest of Modern Who, but I think my reaction to Chibnall Who is more positive than Davies Who now. It feels like me growing away from the show more than the show growing away from me.

I was really busy last winter and hour-long drama fell out of my life, so I'm only now getting around to the last two thirds of the season.

@shirasade I'm kind of like that with current Star Trek too. I'm generally happy that it exists and it's a lot better than some previous eras, but I haven't seen most of Discovery season 2 because I was busy and then it was a lot to catch up on.

@shirasade I keep coming back to how Community's affectionate parody of Doctor Who had a woman play an incarnation of the Inspector, and the fans universally hate her, but claim it's definitely not because she's a woman, it's just that she's terrible in every way.

@tparadox Yes. Especially when they're women. Because it's not as if our entire culture isn't steeped in misogyny. *eyeroll* (It's like Star Wars and Finn. "I just happen to like *other character* better.")

@tparadox I happen to have enjoyed season 2 of Discovery a lot more than season 1, but yeah, it's definitely one of these shows that can fall by the way side.

@shirasade I liked season one of Discovery a lot and I liked what I saw of Discovery Pike even more (though I'm still hesitant about how deep they go with Spock later on), just haven't gotten around to continuing past the third episode yet.

@tparadox yeah, the Spock thing is... unfortunate. But I thought season 2 had a more Classic Trek feel, which I enjoyed. And I'd pay good money for a spin-off with Pike & co. on the Enterprise!

@tparadox That happens for me all the time, albeit not (yet?) with nuWho. There are several shows that I used to watch regularly and just kind of... stopped, for no particular reason.

@shirasade Ugh. I hate it when a bad comment section sours everything.

I enjoyed the heck out of the last season of Doctor Who and I can't wait for the new episodes πŸ˜„

@enchantedsleeper Apparently for New Year's, so not that much longer to wait!

@shirasade The main complaint I've seen (admittedly I don't go looking, lol) is that she's not "dark" or "complex" enough and it's like...

That's a selling point for me! I love that about her! I fucking loathed the DARKER and EDGIER Moffatt years and think they're a blight on pop culture! Moving away from that is A+++++ extreme do want!

So it's like... IDK. 🀷

@alis yeah, I've seen that, too. I love that she's more optimistic, I missed that! Definitely a feature, not a bug
:)
There also seems to be a lot of complaining about the quality of the episodes, as if it wasn't completely normal for every series to have a mix of excellent, good, okay & rubbish eps.

@shirasade I mean if you're the kind of person that complains about the "quality of eps" maybe DOCTOR WHO is not, like. The show for you, y'know? o_O

(Also IMO the people who complain the most about that sort of stuff are generally the ones who're the first to forget that, uh. DOCTOR WHO is technically a kids'/family show? So there are some places it can't full go. And I kinda liked that the last season tried to go back to some of the original "purpose" of it being historical edutainment?)

Sign in to participate in the conversation
fandom.ink

fandom.ink is a community-supported instance designed for fans, fandom, and fandom content creators.